Also, check out our full guide to the top 10 liquors, spirits & drink mix brands. $14.99. Others will pour nothing other than Bacardi because it's what they've been drinking for years. Fill with ice and top with Cherry Cola. As a matter of fact, where grape-based spirits of wine and brandy eventually went bad in the heat of the tropics, rum seemed to improve as it aged in the barrels aboard ship. Often called black strap rum, these rums are very rich, thick, and quite interesting. You may have to search to find one of these, though Cruzan is one of the more widely distributed options. Popular white rums include Bacardi Superior, Don Q Cristal, Cruzan Estate Light, Oronoco, Mount Gay Silver, Matusalem Plantino, Rubi Rey, 10 Cane, Flor de Caa Extra Dry and Diplomatico Rum Blanco. Typical brands sold locally include some of the usual suspects: Bacardi, Captain, and Kraken, as well as some others: Flor de Caa and Matasulem. Most rum is bottled at 40 percent alcohol by volume (ABV, 80 proof), though some reach into the 90 proof range. Charl loves to learn about new products and tries everything he writes about. Examples of black rums include Coruba, Cruzan Black Strap, Goslings Black Seal, Maui Dark Rum, Myerss, Skipper Demerara, Woods 100, and Whalers Dark. Take a long spoon and quickly stir together. This means that you can explore brands without going broke. It is well known as a mix with cola (rum & coke), ginger beer, tropical fruits (mango, pineapple, and papaya), and lemonade. Theyre also used in cooking recipes that call for rum to be ignited in flame (flamb) or drinks that blend a very strong rum into their recipe. Pussers Rum is made from real sugar cane and molasses as well as dried fruit, natural spices and caramel. Sailor Jerry is a spiced rum distilled in the United States Virgin Islands. Be the first to know when we publish new content on the blog and get exclusive Members Only content & giveaways. Captain Morgan Black Spiced Rum When it comes to choosing a brand of rum and looking for alternatives, Captain Morgan is usually always a good idea. Most rums can be classified in one or more of a few distinct categories. One of the most top rated rums for mixing in splendid cocktails, this one boasts of rich flavours of vanilla, brown sugar and aromatic spices, topped off with a hint of oak and a beautifully balanced, smooth finish. These aromatic and pungent vegetal substances often provide excitement and zest to sweeter liquids. After three years of maturing, the rhums are labeled rhum vieux (old rum). Prior to this, if a rum connoisseur managed to obtain a tot or two, it was valued for a very special occasion. These bottles are pretty high-octane, with ABVs ranging from about 55 percent to a hefty 64 percent. For example, Zacapa Centenario 23 from Guatemala is a blend of rums aged 6 to 23 years old. With its spicy flavor, Captain Morgan pairs well with drinks like cola and ginger beer and, in 2014, was the second most popular spirit in the United States. It is a dark, golden brown color and is aged for three years using a blend of column and pot still distillation. Captain Morgan The Original Rum Review - thefatrumpirate.com These include the high-end Estate Reserve, a 15-year-old spirit that is best enjoyed neat or maybe with a large ice cube; 3 Star, which is aged for four years despite the name; and Pango Rhum, an aged rum that is flavored with macerated pineapples and mangos. Most rum is made from molasses, a thick, dark sweet liquid left over in the process of manufacturing crystallized sugar. Spiced rum on the other hand is usually a mild rum with a lot of flavour additives, often vanilla, sometimes cloves, cinnamon, nutmeg or ginger. If you are looking for something with zero additives, you are in luck. I have a decent collection of rum, but I've never tasted Pusser's by itself, so I'm not sure which rum(s) would be a suitable replacement without changing the characteristics of the drink too much. Goslings vs Meyers vs Pussers : r/rum - Reddit Compare Captain Morgan vs. Pusser's Rum side-by-side. Some gold rums are blends of rums of various ages, and others are straight rum aged for a specific amount of time. And its not that rum is totally unregulated. They have pussers and several similar dark rums that make very good tasting and strong painkillers. The rich flavour of Pussers Rum is all natural-- no artificial flavouring or colouring is added. Use a long spoon and give a quick stir to blend all of the ingredients. Just like all rum, the lack of regulations and disclosures should make the flavored rum drinker more cautious when shopping. Aged rums generally take on darker and richer colors due to the time spent in barrels. Shop From VS Liquor's Large Selection Including Rare & Specialty Bottles. Best Rum for Cake Baking | Alices Kitchen Pusser's British Navy Blue Label 40 3-Year | Rum Ratings In the Andean region, the spirit is often enjoyed straight. While previous versions were made with vodka, the current offering uses Other Than Standard orange wine as the boozy addition. Fill a glass with ice a little more than halfway. One problem that rum has faced over the years is its reputation as an unregulated, duplicitous spirit. If you have never tasted these two brands, you may wonder which is better in flavor, taste, and price. There are high-priced bottles out there, but most are affordable for the average drinker. The main difference is the color. Like in the production of fine wines, in some years the harvest is bountiful, while others are not as abundant. Or, maybe its that you are looking for another brand of dark rum to try and expand your palette when it comes to this type of liquor. The Hamilton Overproof Rum 151 is a bit pricier than the other options and is typically sold for over 430 per bottle. .css-gk9meg{display:block;font-family:Lausanne,Arial,sans-serif;font-weight:normal;margin-bottom:0;margin-top:0;padding-top:0.25rem;-webkit-text-decoration:none;text-decoration:none;}@media (any-hover: hover){.css-gk9meg:hover{color:link-hover;}}@media(max-width: 48rem){.css-gk9meg{font-size:1.125rem;line-height:1.15;margin-bottom:0.25rem;}}@media(min-width: 40.625rem){.css-gk9meg{font-size:1rem;line-height:1.2;margin-bottom:0.625rem;}}@media(min-width: 64rem){.css-gk9meg{font-size:1.25rem;line-height:1.2;}}@media(min-width: 73.75rem){.css-gk9meg{font-size:1.25rem;line-height:1.2;}}The Best Canned Cocktails, The Cup of Coffee That Tastes Like a Summer Night, The 7 Best Wine Openers, According to Wine Experts, 14 Whiskey Glasses For Your Top-Shelf Pours, 9 Best Wine Decanters, According to the Experts, The Hands-Down Best Irish Whiskey to Drink in 2023, This Tequila Enthusiast Has Found His New Favorite, 12 Glasses That'll Do Your Single Malts Justice. The bold flavors make it a good option if you choose to drink solely on the rocks and not as part of a cocktail. Pussers is completely different. All content is for informational and educational purposes only. Pussers Rum has a distinct, bold flavor that makes any beverage even better. Captain Morgan is nothing like the sickly sweet "navy" rums such as Skipper and Lambs. This dark rum isnt the strongest mentioned substitute but instead brings the caribbean flavors to life throughout the blend. Bayou Spiced Rum is more expensive than Captain Morgan but is a worthy alternative if you a looking to try another quality Spiced rum. It is named after the 17th-century Welsh privateer of the Caribbean, Sir Henry Morgan. Captain Morgan Private Stock Captain Morgan Private Stock is Captain Morgan's premium spiced rum. This inexpensive rum is named after Don Quixote and has been around since the end of Prohibition. Reserva Exclusiva is a dependable spirit to have in your home bar, made in a variety of still types and aged for up to 12 years in oak casks. I would rate Myers's and Coruba to be the better rums according to my tastes though I don't drink much of either these days. Large manufacturers of cachaa use tall column stills of stainless steel to produce vast volumes of spirit in a continuous process, most of which is enjoyed without maturing in barrels. Some popular navy style rums include Lambs Navy Rum, Pussers, Lemon Hart, Skipper Demerara and Woods 100. Foursquare is another Barbados distillery known for making great rum, some of which is sold under other brand names. Many popular drink ingredients in the category of bitters evolved from such intendedly curative mixtures. Leaving the drinker with a smooth, yet slightly spicy kick at the end of the sip. It is impossible to list every brand and label or keep up with portfolio changes and newly released rums. Some of the more popular offerings are available in 1-liter bottles or larger, which can save money if you really like the rum. The Spruce Eats / Cara Cormack. No.13: Captain Morgan's Parrot Bay Coconut Rum Producer: Diageo Rum Origin: Puerto Rico . Captain Morgan - Wikipedia Vintage rums are labeled with the year they were distilled and the location of their origin. Subtle flavors of vanilla, almond, citrus, caramel or coconut may be present from the type of barrels used in the aging process. Don't overlook unknown brands, and be sure to check out craft distilleries. Pusser's was never sold or offered to the public until 1979. Sailor Jerry Rum uses rum blended with secret spices. Spices that are detected are vanilla, ginger, cloves, and cinnamon. The main difference is the color. Well, it hasnt quite happened yet, and that might actually be a good thing. The Lemon Hart brand was registered in 1888 and remains to this day a popular staple of naval-style rums. Subscribe to get special offers, free giveaways, and once-in-a-lifetime deals from Pusser's Rum. Pusser's British Navy rum today is the same blend of five West Indian rums as the British Admiralty issued to sailors. You may find that some of the lesser-known brands are superior in taste and mixability. In 1979, with the Admiralty's blessing Charles Tobias, resurrected the navy's rum as a commercial brand after securing . Then, Sailor Jerry Ltd. expanded its company to create Sailor Jerry Spiced Rum in 1991. Martinique is the only geographic region in the world to have an AOC mark in the rum industry. Tennessee Whiskey can only be produced in you guessed it Tennessee. Rums labeled premium or ultra-premium often contain age statements. Robs Rum Guide offers guidance and advice about the many different categories, styles and types of rum produced around the world. 6.8/10. An advantage for the Hamilton Overproof Rum 151 is that it is considered a great option for a Mai Tai, whereas the Pussers Rum, isnt necessarily recommended for that cocktail. The modern distillation process produces a spirit that is generally 160 to 190 proof alcohol. The Capitan Bucanero Rum Reserva is sold for under $20 per bottle and gives the flavors of vanilla, coconut and fruit which will transport you to the Dominican Republic where the Capitan Bucanero Rum Reserva is made. These types of rum tend to be limited editions that are valuable to collectors and serious rum enthusiasts. Jonah Flicker is a freelance writer who covers booze, food, travel, and lifestyle for a variety of publications. The extensive aging process that takes place to make even just one barrel of Pussers Rum is what allows it to be one of the most popular brands of rum on the market as well as one of the best quality rums on the market. The higher-end Ambassador is also quite good, a rum aged for a minimum of 12 years in white oak before being finished for two years in PX sherry casks. Sailor Jerry has enough flavor to drink straight or on the rocks; however, its authentic flavors come to life with simple mixes such as cola (rum &coke) or ginger beer. Captain Morgan's use to make a navy rum for the Canadian navy, but it's hard to find any information on it. Between the recipes and even close substitutions, there are plenty of ways to enjoy a delicious beverage and discover all that Pussers Rum has to offer. Because its the Royal Navys blending process of Pussers Rum that allows it to be that delicious liquor it continues to be today. A few cocktails were designed for a particular dark rum. Bacardi is the biggest rum distillery in Puerto Rico, but Destileria Serralles makes what might be the most popular as far as the locals are concerned: Don Q. Hence the use of pirates on the logo of some other named brand rums. There's a special set of rums that are even stronger. After the British navy stopped issuing tots in 1970 and the Canadian Navy . They are used in specific cocktails and can become a substitute for other rums when you want to add more flavor. The Plantation Original Dark Rum is also found in the same price range as the majority of the other substitutes, ranging from $20-$25 per bottle. Steps to Make It. Best Rum to Use With Rum and Coke - Modded The final supply of old British Royal Navy Imperial Rum, representing the spirit of international adventure, honor and bravery on the high seas, have recently been re-bottled and are available for the most serious rum collectors. The rum is aged in oak barrels in Guyana and then bottled at 54.5% ABV. There is much more to the story of Pussers Rum than just being the main ingredient to the Painkiller cocktail. Many rum cocktails call for a white or light rum, a gold rum and/or dark or spiced rum. And it is a fact that for over 300 years it was a tradition of the British Navy that each member of the crew was issued a daily 'tot' of rum. Check All Stores. Another tropical cocktail to choose from if you are looking for something a little less strong than a painkiller, the Hurricane may be the drink to try. Pusser's Alternative for Painkiller? : r/cocktails - Reddit Try both and decide. This gives it a distinctly sweet oakey taste. U.S. regulations prevent rums over 155 proof from entering the U.S. under most circumstances, so many manufacturers produce rums in the 150 proof range, such as Bacardi 151, Cruzan 151, El Dorado 151 High Strength Rum, Bruddah Kimios Da Bomb 155, Goslings 151 and Matusalem 151 Red Flame. Captain Morgan Spiced Rum 375 ml Bottle. One of which (Pusser's) is based on the original recipe and the other is a rum which was deliberately sourced because it matched (as closely as possible) to the Black Tot rum. The term Dark Rum is essentially meaningless. The lighter rhums agricole are rested for up to six months before being bottled as rhum blanc. From Demerara River Valley's sugarcane molasses, it was distilled using wooden pots through age-old . Vintage rums are most often seen from the French islands, where the growing and processing season is short. Explore our wide selection of more than 3,000 spirits. When you think of a Dark n Stormy, Goslings would like you to think of its rum, and its rum alone. However, this is complemented with a delicate hint of allspice and dark pepper to give it a bit more kick. Gold rums are used to make cocktails in which a stronger flavor is desired. In comparison, Plantation has Caribbean roots as well, having been made with rum directly from Barbados and Jamaica. In the 1990s, they started making Sailor Jerry Rum. Theyre often used in the popular cocktail known as petit punch (ti punch) mixed with lime and cane syrup. Try Rhum JMs white rum to really experience how unique the spirit is, with grassy and earthy notes that complement this pleasantly dry, unaged rhum. Each popsicle is only 100 calories and contains nary an artificial sweetener. When nosed it smells very similar to Pussers. Captain Morgan vs Pusser's Rum: Side-by-Side Comparison Sailor Jerry has modified its formula to provide a sweeter taste with a reduced alcohol strength of 35 ABV% to appeal to a larger audience in the UK. Pour the rum, pineapple juice, orange juice, and cream of coconut into a cocktail shaker filled with ice. Holmes Cay is focused on one thing: releasing the best single cask rum it can find, with no sugar or adulterants added. The Ginger Sea Dog cocktail is enjoyed best in a mule mug and is another type of island mixture. Aging in oak casks was not possible, so they blended in spices. A Guide to Popular Rum Brands by Style and Price - The Spruce Eats The cost of storage and the loss of some rum from the barrels through evaporation adds to the cost of producing aged rums. The biggest problem I have with Captain Morgan is that the rum it is most similar to, Pussers is just so so much better. Sailor Jerry uses a selection of the best high-proof rums distilled in the Caribbean and infuses it with their secret spices.. Also . If you have never tasted these two brands, you may wonder which is better in flavor, taste, and price. $29.99. We compared Captain Morgan vs Pusser's Rum on key criteria, based on outside expert reviews and our own analysis of each vendor's products, services, and websites. Flavored rums, including spiced rum and coconut rum, are not as essential. Fruit extracts of citrus, cherry, mint, black currant, coconut, mango, pineapple, banana and other tropical plants and trees bring luscious tones to flavored rum varieties. Read the label on gold-coloredrums to learn a bit about their production (not all are revealing, however). After filling the mule full of ice, pour two ounces of Pussers Rum and six ounces of Ginger Beer over the ice. Captain Morgan came first when The Seagram Company started selling the brand under the (The Captain Morgan Rum Company) name. It looks like this topic was brought up about a year ago, but I didn't see too many suggestions in the thread so I figured I'd bring it up again. Drink Stack is a resource for adults of legal drinking age. It has a similar texture to Bacardi, but a slightly sweeter taste of Virgin Islands liquor. 1997 Vintage from Martinique, Plantation Venezuela 1992 and the 1998 Vintage from Foursquare Rum Distillery in Barbados. Light rum will be your first choice for most rum cocktails,including favorites like the mojito. Captain Morgan Private Stock is Captain Morgans premium spiced rum. Both are more popular in mixed drinks but are smooth enough to enjoy straight. Unlike the other listed brands that would make for optional substitutes, Navy Bay Rum, isnt the most widely known name. He lives in Brooklyn with his wife, two daughters, and one cairn terrier. Brugal Gold Rum This dark rum from the Dominican Republic strikes a great balance between sweet and spicy. The Cruzan Aged Dark Rum can also be found for under $20 a bottle which is a bit cheaper than the Pussers Rum. Know someone shopping for Captain Morgan or Pusser's Rum? Choose a store to get price . Pour three ounces of Pussers Rum into a hurricane glass full of ice. We know that Scotch is produced in only one place: Scotland. Joy Skipper / Photolibrary / Getty Images. This Kraken Black Spiced Rum is 70 Proof and retails for $11.99. If none of the rums listed below work as a sub, are there any others out there that will? Both rums are best mixed or in cocktails. It has a sweet, neutral flavor that pairs well with almost any flavor, and its clear color doesn't affect the drink's appearance. Diplomtico is produced in Venezuela from molasses and sugarcane honey, which the distillery describes as the syrup left over after the first boiling of sugarcane, with a higher sugar content than molasses. Other territories have differing standards. Pusser's 350 years of liquid history has become the standard by which other dark rums are measured. Sailor Jerry Vs Captain Morgan (UPDATED 2023) - DrinkStack But, the aging process takes place in barrels in France. Sailor Jerry and Captain Morgan offer spiced rum at similar prices and are better mixed with cola or ginger beer or blended into cocktails.